Read Slav says Randolph is our cup keeper, he is playing very well but IMO Adrian is better. So how many more rounds would you be prepared to play him assuming we progress?
I know hes played decent when called upon but i actually don't think Randolph is that good. His supposd triple save for example against liverpool, came because he couldnt keep hold of a shot that was at him and then the next shot also went at him. IMO he saves most that he should save, but makes it harder for himself at times. Adrian on the other hand just has that confidence about him that re assures me with him in goal e.g in our win against southampton they piled on pressure and i watched him collect a cross he didnt have the right to catch then he almost set up lanzini for a 3rd goal. I honestly don't think randolph should play at all but that would be unfair
Disagree - Adrian is a step above, better than Randolph, better than Green. Randolph has played well during the Cup run but Adrian would of saved that goal today
Randolph has done ok when called upon but Adrian would be my first choice in all games. As for the discussion about Miklosko, I have to agree that he was something of a cult figure and nothing special.
I would rate Green, Hislop & James as better 'keepers than him.
As good a keeper in his prime I thought Green was. He was unfortunately very poor from all types of set pieces. But to be honest, Fabio Capello shot his confidence to pieces.
Green was a better 'keeper than Miklosko 7 days a week and at least on a par with both Hislop and James IMO.
But there it is, differing opinions, we will never all agree will we.
Nice to be in a position with two first class keepers. Adrian slightly better especially on keeping out shots that are on the ground to the corners and those to the top corners where Randolph sometimes cant reach.
I know hes played decent when
I know hes played decent when called upon but i actually don't think Randolph is that good. His supposd triple save for example against liverpool, came because he couldnt keep hold of a shot that was at him and then the next shot also went at him. IMO he saves most that he should save, but makes it harder for himself at times. Adrian on the other hand just has that confidence about him that re assures me with him in goal e.g in our win against southampton they piled on pressure and i watched him collect a cross he didnt have the right to catch then he almost set up lanzini for a 3rd goal. I honestly don't think randolph should play at all but that would be unfair
If he's the cup goalkeeper,
If he's the cup goalkeeper, then he plays all the way to the final. Not much to choose between him and Adrian. Neither are actually great keepers.
Disagree - Adrian is a step
Disagree - Adrian is a step above, better than Randolph, better than Green. Randolph has played well during the Cup run but Adrian would of saved that goal today
Adrian is the best keeper we
Adrian is the best keeper we have has since Phil parkes
I agree that Adrian is better
I agree that Adrian is better. However we must give credit to Randolph .He is always ready with good performance
Imo...
We are blessed to have 2 very good keepers!
Randolph has done ok when
Randolph has done ok when called upon but Adrian would be my first choice in all games. As for the discussion about Miklosko, I have to agree that he was something of a cult figure and nothing special.
I would rate Green, Hislop & James as better 'keepers than him.
I agree with that lenuse
I agree with that lenuse
As good a keeper in his prime
As good a keeper in his prime I thought Green was. He was unfortunately very poor from all types of set pieces. But to be honest, Fabio Capello shot his confidence to pieces.
Green was a better 'keeper
Green was a better 'keeper than Miklosko 7 days a week and at least on a par with both Hislop and James IMO.
But there it is, differing opinions, we will never all agree will we.
As I said mate, Green was not
As I said mate, Green was not helped by capello in the slightest
Win or loose keep him
Win or loose keep him
Nice to be in a position with
Nice to be in a position with two first class keepers. Adrian slightly better especially on keeping out shots that are on the ground to the corners and those to the top corners where Randolph sometimes cant reach.